Tata Steel 2013 thread

(Since this is the super-tournament du jour, I thought an open thread to discuss it might be useful.)

Five decisive games out of seven in the “A” Group in today’s fourth round - and none of them involved the US Champion. Nakamura has drawn all four of his games - the only player without a decisive result to this point. Can’t really complain about such a result at this level, but his near-loss to Sokolov with white in round 2 is cause for concern.

The big story of the day appears to be the game Aronian-Anand: 0-1, 23 moves.

Carlsen, Anand and Karjakin lead the “A” Group after four rounds with 3 points each. None of them have played yet. Nakamura is in the massive fourth-place logjam with 2 points.

The tournament site can be seen here. Cool live-game feeds and post-game interviews.

Anand is actually playing well for a change. Last time Anand finished with a plus-score in any top tier tournament was Corus 2011.

Nakamura picked up a black win today against Hou Yifan.

No problem. He’ll just knock over Aronian and Carlsen later in the tournament and win :slight_smile:

With nine rounds in the books, Carlsen (+5) has a one-point lead over Anand (+3) after beating Hou today. Those two, along with Nakamura, are the only players to not yet suffer a loss.

Carlsen has pushed his live rating to 2869.7. Anand has gained over 11 points in this event so far, and is back in the top 5 on live ratings as of now.

Nakamura appeared to be flirting with disaster today against Giri, but held the draw. He’s tied for third with Aronian on +2.

To approach 2900, one has to score 70+% against 2700s. Carlsen’s performance is approaching the ridiculous.

Nakamura is now tied for first among mere mortals.

As Mr. Brock noted, Carlsen’s at it again. After beating L’Ami today, he goes to +6, leading the tournament by a point and a half with three rounds to go.

Anand drew with Karjakin today, staying on +3 in second place. He was joined by Aronian and Nakamura, who disposed of Wang and Caruana, respectively. Aronian has responded impressively after getting wasted by Anand early in the event. Nakamura, who picked up a black win against the Italian champion, remains undefeated, along with Carlsen and Anand.

Tomorrow is a rest day; the tournament closes with three more rounds Friday-Sunday. Looking ahead at the leaders’ schedules…

Carlsen plays black against Wang, white against Nakamura and black against Giri.
Anand plays black against Hou, white against L’Ami and black against Wang.
Nakamura plays white against Aronian, black against Carlsen and white against Harikrishna.
Aronian plays black against Nakamura, white against Giri and black against Caruana.

Carlsen is on the verge of closing out yet another top tournament. His most likely stumbling block is Nakamura, but he’ll have white, and Nakamura has never beaten Carlsen in a classical time control with black. Among the second-place trio, Anand seems to have the “easiest” remaining schedule, as he’s played all the other front-runners. However, he’ll have to be pretty ambitious in his remaining games to catch Carlsen; he will likely need at least 2.5 of his last 3. Nakamura-Aronian is a critical game on Friday.

Very beautiful combination by Nakamura yesterday. It’s beyond most of our abilities to find over-the-board (in this setting, we know that something is in the position), but it’s easy enough for a bright beginner to understand.

Caruana-Nakamura
In this position, White to play is in check; he blundered with 1.Kc2?
After that, it’s Black to play and win

Carlsen was never in any danger against Wang today, and drew comfortably. He remains a massive +6 after 11 rounds.

Aronian, meanwhile, has come all the way back from that crushing early loss to Anand. He beat Nakamura today - with black, no less - and now is in clear second place at +4, a point behind Carlsen with two rounds to go.

The aforementioned Anand had what I thought was a winning advantage around move 40 against Hou, but let it slip away and eventually drew the former women’s world champion to slip to clear third place, on +3. Anand and Carlsen remain the only two undefeated players. But Anand really needed to win today to entertain serious thoughts of catching Carlsen for the lead.

Nakamura is now tied for fourth on +2 with Karjakin and Leko, who conjured up a R+P endgame win against van Wely.

Tomorrow’s Carlsen-Nakamura game should be very interesting; I suspect neither player will be in the mood for a quick draw.

EDIT: updated post to reflect result of Leko - van Wely (1-0).

It will be refreshing not to have to listen to arguments about whether Fischer, Kasparov, or Capablanca was the greatest player ever.

Carlsen 1 - Nakamura 0 with frightening speed.

tatasteelchess.com/tournament/livegames

Not so much, it seems.

Carlsen took advantage of an ill-advised 21st move by Nakamura to roll to the win today. With the win, Carlsen goes to +7 in the tournament, good enough to sew up first place with a round to spare. His performance rating through 12 rounds is 2952. He also pushes his live rating to 2874.

For 2700-type players, gaining 15 points in 3 months is a serious accomplishment. Carlsen, the world’s highest rated player by a healthy margin, has gained 13 points in this event alone. Put another way, as of this writing, there is no one in the world rated within 60 points of Carlsen - and only five players rated within 100 points.

Anand was able to beat L’Ami today and move back into a tie for second with Aronian, who got absolutely nowhere as white against Giri. Anand has gained about 13 points from this event as well.

A few other notes in the “A” group: Sokolov continued his blunderfest today, simply walking into a winning continuation for his opponent, Hou. He’s at a shocking -7 for this event, and has yet to win a game. Meanwhile, Hou is at a very creditable -2, performing about 80 points above her rating. If this is any indication, Anna Ushenina is on borrowed time as women’s world champion.

Harikrishna continues to acquit himself well in his “A” group debut, drawing Wang to keep a level score. His live rating has gone over 2700. Caruana’s rating is in free fall - after losing to van Wely today, he’s lost 25 points in Wijk aan Zee.

In the “B” group, 17-year-old sensation Richard Rapport is co-leader with GM Sergei Movsesian. The winner of the “B” group is invited to the following year’s “A” group. Dutch legend Jan Timman was among the leaders for a while, but has lost his last few games to fall back into the pack.

In the “C” group, GMs Fernando Peralta and Sabino Brunello are +8, 2.5 points clear of their nearest competition. Unfortunately, they’ve already played one another. :slight_smile:

Well, it looks like it might be set in stone that the Carlsen will be the next world champion…

This Carlson is like the Daigo Umehara and Justin Wong of the chess world…

Hardly. Carlsen still needs to win the Candidates tournament and then defeat Anand in a match. While I’d agree it certainly looks like the odds are with Carlsen, there’s no guarantee.

Great tournament results do not necessarily result in becoming world champion. Some of the great interzonal winners during the 50s, 60s, and 70s were not able to continue their streak into the candidates match.

1952: Kotov scores 16.5/20 in the Interzonal, ties for 8th-9th (out of 15) in the Candidates.
1955: Bronstein scores 15/20 in the Interzonal, ties for 3rd-7th (out of 10) in the Candidates
1962: Fischer scores 17.5/22 in the Interzonal, 4th (out of :sunglasses: in Candidates
1979: Tal scores 14/17 in the Interzonal, loses in Candidates QF match 5.5-2.5.

In addition to a player’s level of play at a particular point in time, there can always be “Non-chess” variables such as:

  • Personal health (e.g., Mikhail Tal’s kidneys). And in the 1977 Candidates, in a great moment of chess sportsmanship, after Boris Spassky underwent an emergency appendectomy with the match score tied, Vlastimil Hort used his remaining timeout to give Spassky additional time to recover. Spassky then won the final game and the match. Not all of today’s top-20 players would do that for an opponent.

  • Family’s health (e.g., Spouse’s serious accident/illness).

  • War/Politics: Emanuel Lasker’s health suffered in post-World War I Germany; and after winning AVRO 1938 Paul Keres never got play Alexander Alekhine for the world championship due to WWII (1939-1945).

candidates match is right around the corner… :exclamation:

Discovery of/involvement with the opposite sex: Bobby Fischer Buenos Aires 1960, Harry Nelson Pillsbury Hastings 1895 :laughing:

Didnt Tal, once while playing in central/south america, get caught being too amorous with someone who turned out to be taken and this resulted in the guy breaking a bottle over his head?

I think that has to involve some combination of all the above reasons, and surely Tal couldn’t have played well from there.

Edit: confirmed here: chessbase.com/newsdetail.asp?newsid=7706

also some other good stories there.

Carlsen 50%, Kramnik 20%, Aronian 15%, field 15%.

If we still had candidates matches, Carlsen would be tough to beat.

O.K., I give up. How does Black win after 1.Kc2? All I can see is 1…Rd4 2.Re1 Bb4 (with a possible rook invasion at d2), but after 3.Re2 White seems to have everything covered. If 1…Bb4 2.Rf2 again covers d2 and allows the rook to defend the knight (2…Rd4 3.Re2). So what’s the solution?

  1. … g4 2. hxg4 h3 3. gxh3 Rf8. Instead of gxh3, the Black h-pawn became a monster.