Aside from the numbers that begin with a 2, the ID number can give a reasonable estimate of when that ID was assigned. We know the 10 numbers were part of the initial numbering, done by state, moving more or less from east to west. The 11 numbers were ones issued after that, assigned sequentially. That got changed to 12 around 1980, probably the result of a software update. There were not many 11 ID’s issued.
I started getting involved in membership processing in 2003, we were in the 128’s or 129’s by then.
During the 80’s and 90’s the office would periodically purge the member file of inactive lapsed members to save disk space, which was quite limited back then. So we do not have records for every member during that era. The last time I checked there were still around 500 IDs in tournaments on MSA that do not correspond to an ID in the membership database because that ID had been purged. If we ever scan the old rating supplements and make them available, we might be able to use OCR processing and find those deleted IDs.
Around 129 we started adding a check digit, because we were getting many instances of transposed IDs (12345687 instead of 12345678) being valid once we went to online rating report submission. The check digit meant that a single transposition or one-digit typo in an ID almost always resulted in an invalid ID, but it also meant that we were using up blocks of numbers 10 times faster than before.
Just before we switched to the 3’s in July of 2020, we were assigning IDs starting with 173.
There’s no geographic pattern and not much of a date pattern to the IDs that begin with a 2, because the office would send TDs a bundle of pre-numbered forms, and they didn’t always send them out in order, and TDs would use them over a period of months or years. The biggest problem with them was that kids would lose their copy and not know their IDs and the TD at their next event would just pull out a new green form and give them a new ID, because there was no way to look them up online and getting a published rating took several months, due to both lags in event processing and in creating, printing and sending out a rating supplement.
A few years ago Judy told me they still saw one of those pre-numbered green forms every few months for a new player. I think I’ve still got a handful of them in an old TD bag, along with some wall charts, quad charts, pairing sheets, pairing cards and possibly a few adjourned move envelopes.